Skip to content
Call us on 01603 251730

Independent Evaluation of Croydon's Best Start Family Hubs

Croydon has been developing its Best Start Family Hubs programme to make it easier for families to access joined-up support, strengthen early intervention and improve outcomes for children, young people and families.

The programme brings together a range of services and partners, including local authority services, health, early years provision and voluntary and community organisations.

Croydon commissioned us to undertake an independent evaluation of its Best Start Family Hubs transformation programme.

The evaluation was designed to assess progress against the programme's objectives, understand the experiences of families and professionals, examine the development of integrated working and provide evidence to inform future planning and service development.

Our approach

Interface undertook a comprehensive mixed-method evaluation, combining qualitative and quantitative research to examine programme implementation, delivery and progress.

Our work included:

  • 27 individual interviews with senior leaders, commissioners, service managers, Family Navigators, practitioners and voluntary sector providers.
  • Direct engagement with 26 parents and carers, through individual interviews and small-group discussions, to understand their experiences of accessing and using services.
  • Multi-agency workforce and senior leadership workshops, involving approximately 25 workforce representatives and seven senior leaders.
  • Analysis of programme management information, including service activity, participation, reach and available outcomes data.
  • Review of programme documentation, including strategic and delivery plans, co-production activity, service feedback and workforce development.
  • Assessment against the Common Outcomes Framework, considering programme development and its contribution to intended outcomes for children, young people and families.

Our approach brought together the perspectives of families, frontline practitioners, managers, commissioners and strategic partners alongside programme and performance information.

This enabled us to examine the programme from different perspectives, considering both the delivery of services and the wider partnership and system arrangements supporting implementation.

Reporting and outputs

The evaluation resulted in two complementary reports, each designed for a different purpose and audience.

Independent Evaluation Report for the Department for Education

A comprehensive evaluation report examining the development and implementation of Croydon's Best Start Family Hubs programme.

The report brought together qualitative and quantitative evidence to assess progress against programme objectives and the Common Outcomes Framework. It covered the development of the Family Hub model, access and accessibility, connections between services, relationships and workforce development, and the programme's contribution to intended outcomes for children, young people and families.

The report included conclusions and recommendations to inform future programme development.

Strategic Learning Paper: Moving from Family Hub Development to Whole-System Transformation in Croydon

A separate learning paper was developed specifically to support Croydon's strategic planning for the next phase of Best Start Family Hubs, covering 2026–2029.

Rather than repeating the detailed evaluation evidence and programme information, the paper drew together the principal learning from the evaluation, focusing on implementation, partnership working, leadership and wider system development.

It identified strategic considerations and priority actions to inform the continued development of the Family Hub model.

Together, the two reports provided Croydon with a comprehensive independent evaluation and a focused strategic learning resource to support future planning and decision-making.

Search